Skip to main content

Improving a Whiskey Sour with a Designated Cocktail Syrup

In my Whiskey Sour experiment (and also in the taste of my last Whiskey Sours in the bar), I haven't
been fully convinced about the taste of the whiskey sours.

I did everything right: used quality bourbon, used proper ice, shook long enough, used fresh lemon...
yet the whiskey sour was slightly too lemony - it had enough alcohol, the right sweetness, the sourness - yet it was somewhat off. No - it was not somewhat off - let me rephrase it - I was not 100% satisfied with the results. It wasn't as good as the Whiskey Sour in front of my imaginary eye (or on my imaginary tastebuds).

Not that I tried a Whiskey Sour in another bar which has been better...

That sounds crazy to you? Welcome to my world...

The problem is that: as soon as I will change the ratios, the cocktail will also loose its balance... and to be honest, I don't really think, that solely tinkering with the ratios, will bring me anywhere...

I have been breaking down how to improve cocktails before on this blog. Look at every single ingredients and use the best suitable (that doesn't necessarily mean most expensive):

  • Bourbon: 
    • Yes for a proper Whiskey Sour, you need bourbon. Rye sour is not bad at all... but the sweetness and intensity of Bourbon works just better... there is a reason, why the Whiskey Sour is an evergreen and no other "sour" is overtaking it. 
    • You would need an intense Bourbon: best would be a bottle in Bond (about 50%) or similar stronger variation. My current favorites are Knob Creek (nutty, intense, cararmel'y, awesome), Elijah Craig (classic, classy, intense, typical bourbon aromas: vanilla, clove, hint of allspice, oak), Four Roses Small Batch (slightly fruitier, but also awesome, vanilla, cherry, spice).
    • It doesn't need to be a straight (barrel finish would be interesting) - but as most more unique Bourbons are only available in the US - you should be your own judge...
  • Lemon:
    • As much as I love the smell of Meyer Lemons, it just confuses the characteristics of the Whiskey Sour - try to stay classic.
    • Fresh lemon juice only - if pre-pressed - ensure, that it is not older than 8 hours (refrigerated). 
    • Be careful, not to get too much lemon oils from the peel into the juice/drink. Seriously, it doesn't seem to be a factor, but it certainly is. Lemon should give the sour its sourness and a slight fresh lemon'y edge - not a "lemon-drop aroma".
  • Ice:
    • Ensure that the ice cubes are full and that the ice doesn't carry a lot of surface water, which would over dilute the drink.
  • Rich syrup:
    • Yeah - should be rich - 2-to-1 ratio - which keeps the water (dilution) at bay.
    • White sugar (or at least light organic sugar) - no Demerara or other sugars.
    • And here - the real story starts...
As you can see - there is not much, what you could do with the Bourbon (the "flaw" of the Whiskey Sour was not, that the Bourbon was not right...) or the lemon... and it was for sure not the rich syrup. 

However while it is (at this stage?) difficult to procure some specific lemon-subspecies with lower lemon'iness. There seems a lot of opportunity to tinker with the syrup.

At this stage people are just using maple syrup, sugar or Demerara sugar instead of normal rich syrup. This is obviously also a way - but it will distract from the whiskey and ultimately make a different cocktail.

This new "opinionated-alchemist" concept (you have seen, what I did here?) is, to augment the typical aromas of Bourbon and make a syrup, which just "tingles" specific facets out of the distillate:

  • Vanilla - one of the most recognizable aromas in bourbon is vanilla - which derives directly out of the virgin heavily charred barrels. no other spirit has this bold aroma - not even rye. 
  • Caramel - this goes hand in hand with vanilla. It is the charred oak. And let's face it - a lot of people love Bourbons, which are just caramel'y. Especially when they are slightly older.
  • Dried fruits - these facets are less prominent. Yet especially dried apricot, peach and cherry aromas are often found. They just mustn't take over, as otherwise the spirit drifts into other categories (other oak aged distillates often also carry dried fruit aromas).
  • Baking spices - Off course - this is also often found in other spirits - however maybe even more than dried fruits, baking spices are making bourbons complex. you can find usually notes of nutmeg, cinnamon, clove, allspice aromas in rum. Again - it never should be too much, otherwise the aroma distracts and goes towards other spirits.
  • Nuts - similar to baking spices nuts are emphasizing on the aged oak character.
  • Dried coconut - this might surprise, but whiskey experts know, that there is always a hint of dried coconut in Bourbons - which derives also from the charred white oak barrels. Obviously the coconut mustn't be really noticeable - only a trace should be there.
As you can see, in theory it seems not especially difficult to replicate a syrup, which emphasizes on the characters of a Whiskey Sour.

The question though is, should the syrup be especially concocted for a specific Bourbon (or: is this even possible?) or should it be a generic Whiskey Sour Syrup?

To directly start with a base which has more X-flavor, I would start with a fermented rich syrup (based on Water-Kefir).

Furthermore - I will for sure add some citric acid to the syrup. It sounds slightly awkward, but it has a very important reason: you can reduce the lemon juice, without loosing sweet/sour balance. And as an additional benefit, the syrup would stay longer.

Now it is just for you to wait, until some experiments are conducted (and probably, I will sleep out my upcoming hangover...). So- stay tuned.


Popular posts from this blog

How to use citric acid - and why you might not want to use it anyway!

To be honest, I shied away of this topic, because I think, people can misinterpret this - big time. I don't want to be part of the problem - I want to be part of the solution!  But when Chris, over at A Bar Above  discussed this subject- I literally could not resist to join into "the discussion". Here is the video: I - however take a bit slower approach than Chris. What is citric acid? Chemical Compound Citric acid is a weak organic acid with the formula C6H8O7. It is a natural preservative/conservative and is also used to add an acidic or sour taste to foods and drinks. Wikipedia Formula: C6H8O7 Molar Mass: 192.124 g/mol Melting Point: 153C Density: 1.66 g/cm3 Boiling point: 175C Soluble in: Water Why is it controversial? In my "mixology world" it is controversial, as citric acid is the stuff, which makes the nightmarish sour mix [ preferably in powder form ] sour. Yeah - citric acid is the main ingredient in one of the most

Agar-Agar Clarification

Not often, I am posting here things, which are clearly not my ideas... However Dave Arnold is clearly a mad scientist [no, he really is!] - and he posted amazing stuff on his website - no - don't click now - just follow the link later. One of the most impressive posts about mixology, besides of demystifying the mechanics of shaking, were clarification techniques. Look, after him, you could use a centrifuge [which would set you back a couple thousand bucks] and a chemical compound, which solidifies sediments. I am not a fan of that. Then there is gelatine clarification; this works quite well [I tried it several times my self] - you gelatinize a liquid [with little gelatine only], freeze it, thaw it [in the fridge] over a colander and a muslin cloth. Thats it. Unfortunately this has several problems: Gelatine is made out of animal bones - hence it is neither vegetarian nor vegan, which you won't usually expect of a beverage. You have to freez

King Robert II Vodka

Who would knew, that I am reviewing a budget vodka here - on the But this isn't a normal review. I skip the marketing perception and use this product to cut directly to the case: Vodka is a "rather" neutral, colorless, "rather" flavorless and odorless distilled beverage from any agricultural source - and depending on the country, it has a minimum of 37.5% and 40% abv. As I said time and time again before: at times it is absolutely nonsense to talk about premium and luxury, when the original product doesn't really "hold this promise". Luxury water can have luxurious marketing, luxurious packaging, can be even rare and slightly more expensive "to produce". However really it is just water. Maybe it has some nuances to normal water - however those nuances (in a blind-test) are pretty small. Vodka is extremely similar - and the chain of evidence (despite a lot of people trying to proof otherwise) makes it re